How the test was made
We conduct our tests ourselves and test all products as they are intended to be used in reality. In our test of hair oils we allowed four trained hairdressers with different hair types and hair colours use the products. We have used the following parameters as a basis for assessing the products in the test:
Nurturing ability: How soft and re-moisturised did your hair become? Is your hair easier to untangle?
Shine: How shiny did your hair become? Does the oil create lustre? Did it become greasy?
Frizziness: Does the oil effectively reduce frizziness? Does the oil work on different hair types? Does the oil weigh down fine hair?
Consistency: Is the oil easy to apply and distribute through the hair? How affordable is the oil?
During the test the hairdressers assumed a consumer perspective and used the products as their clients would use them. The score is for the total experience of the products in relations to their affordability.
The winner of the test is the classic Moroccan Oil that is based on argan oil and has a spicy, oriental fragrance. The oil is dark orange and the consistency is slightly more viscous than the other oils in the test and both when it is used as a deep conditioning treatment and as a styling product it feels more nurturing than any of the other oils. The products go into the hair well and leave it soft and shiny. It was primarily the test subjects with slightly thicker and coarser hair who appreciated this hair oil. Moroccan Oil does not leave the hair with a sticky feeling and gives fine lustre and visibly reduced frizziness. The price is slightly higher than average, but the product is very economical and is therefore seen as being very affordable and we thereby select it as being the best in the test.
Your hair will immediately become softer and easier to control when you use Lanza Keratin Healing Oil Treatment. It contains keratin that helps to build up the hair from the inside. Its restorative effect makes the hair quickly look less damaged and healthier. It's easy to apply the oil as it has a light formula and only a small amount goes a long way, making it extremely economical. Both thin and thick hair becomes smoother and healthier. Despite the product's light formula, it's easy to remove frizziness without the hair feeling heavy. The softness lasts until the day after washing, still without the hair feeling greasy. Unfortunately the product doesn't create much shine, but it does add some lustre. And a clear plus point is the fact that the oil contains a heat protector. This helps protect and repair the hair as much as possible. There aren't many negatives with Lanza Keratin Healing Oil Treatment, and it easily slips into a top position among hair oils.
Mythic Oil is a free-flowing, completely translucent product based on avocado oil and grape seed oil. The fragrance is mildly floral and feels light and fresh. The slightly thinner formula means that it is most suitable as a styling product and the test subjects with fine to medium-thick hair were the most appreciative of this oil among those who were tested. This oil is slightly more liquid that the others in consistency and is quickly absorbed into the hair, but almost “disappears” in thicker and coarser hair. A very affordable product for those with finer hair who want to have a styling oil that gives shine and softness without weighing down the hair. Mythic Oil gives no feeling of greasiness and is therefore suitable for people who usually have a tendency to get greasy hair from styling products.
Yves Rocher Hair Repair Oil has been developed for very dry and frizzy hair and is intended to moisturise and repair. The three oils that the product contains – macadamia, jojoba and babassu – are often used in many of the more expensive hair oils on the market. These three ingredients are considered to be good and nutritious for the hair, and after use make the hair feel soft, fresh and moisturised. Yves Rocher also try to minimise their environmental impact and extract the oils in an environmentally conscious way. The yellow/brown plastic bottle may certainly reinforce the environmentally conscious impression, but to be perfectly honest it also feels rather boring and cheap.
According to the instructions, you should apply the oil 10 minutes before showering, then rinse it out, rather like a hair mask. This is stated on the back of the bottle and is easy to miss, which means that Hair Repair Oil is often used as a normal hair oil. In this case, you have to be very careful applying it as the hair can otherwise become greasy and heavy. If you use the hair oil as it's intended, it gives extremely good results. For a miracle cure in terms of moisturisation and nutrition, you can apply it in the evening and then shower it out of your hair in the morning. Unfortunately, dry hair requires a great deal of the oil, which means that you go through it quite quickly. But Yves Rocher Hair Repair Oil still feels good value for money and largely delivers what it promises. You can also use it with a clear conscience, given the company's environmental approach.
Kérastase Elixir Ultime is a translucent hair oil based on argan oil, maize oil, a, paraxanthine oil and camellia oil that are all oils known for their nurturing properties. All of the test subjects award the highest scores for its fragrance that is mildly spicy with an undertone reminiscent of cedar wood. The consistency is medium thick and as a styling product is well suited for all of the hair types that used it in this test. As a deep conditioning treatment it is most suitable for people with dry or damaged hair as it feels very nurturing, but feels slightly too heavy for those with fine, healthy hair. Elixir Ultime is the most expensive of the tested oils, but we see it as being a good luxury choice since the oil is economical in use and the results are very good.
Redken All Soft Argan-6, as the name would suggest, is based on argan oil, but also contains Omega-6, which is a fatty acid. The formula is free-flowing and completely translucent and the fragrance is discrete with a spicy undertone. All of the test subjects feel that the oil is very moisturising and gives shine, but those with the driest/most damaged hair think that the effect when All Soft Argan-6 is used as a deep conditioning treatment is not enough. As a styling product it works well for all hair types and above all we feel that it does not weigh the haor down, whether you have thick or fine hair. The frizz-reducing effect is above average and the oil also gives a lot of shine, which makes the hair feel soft and healthy.
Macadamia Natural Oil Treatment is a light yellow, viscous hair oil that has a fantastic spicy fragrance with a hint of vanilla. The oil comes in an attractive glass bottle with a built in pump that makes it easy to apply, but due to the slightly thicker consistency the oil is not felt to be as economical as the other tested products. Macadamia Natural oil is based on macadamia nut oil and argan oil and is quickly absorbed by the hair and the nurturing effect is felt to be above average. The oil makes the hair soft, shiny and frizz-free both when it is used as a deep conditioning treatment and when it is used as a styling product. Macadamia Natural Oil is given the highest score as a styling product by the test subjects who have dry and frizzy hair, while it is felt to be slightly too heavy for the very finest hair.
Wella SP LuxeOil is a great product for anyone with slightly thicker hair. The viscous, slightly thicker consistency of this hair oil makes the hair soft and definitely easier to untangle. However, the oil isn't as good on thinner hair. It can easily feel sticky, making the hair heavy and greasy. The sticky effect also means that it's easy to apply too much oil to thin hair, while you need quite a lot in thicker hair to get a result. The risk that the hair will become greasy also means that it's difficult to use the oil to control frizziness. To avoid a heavy feeling, you want to apply relatively little, but the dilemma then is that the product doesn't give much of a result. In terms of shine, Wella SP LuxeOil is fantastically good, so if you succeed in applying just the right amount you'll be happy with the end result.
Orofluido Hair Oil is based on argan oil, linseed oil and cyperus oil and has quite a strong, spicy fragrance. The oil is quite viscous, dark yellow in colour and comes in a heavy and somewhat bulky glass bottle with quite a large opening, which makes it difficult to apply. Unfortunately, the difficulty of application together with the thick consistency means that it is not felt to be economical in use. The oil is quickly absorbed by the hair and makes it shiny and soft, but the nurturing effect is somewhat below average. Orofluido Hair Oil is most suited for thicker hair where as a styling product it is very effective against frizziness without making the hair greasy.